It's literally possible. Rose was a better and more efficient hitter and a better fielder. Rose is a first ballot HOF'er without the betting.
Bagwell was a better hitter, Rose was a better baserunner (maybe) and fielder. Rose was a great hitter but he was also an accumulator. Bagwell hit for power and average and had an awesome career on base percentage, the problem for him is that people suspect that he used steroids.