Defense is a joke. The "y" move will get you a bucket about 80% of the time and I played a game yesterday when I scored 68 with Kirk Hinrich.
Well you're really not supposed to try to do that. I could score 100 with Shaq just dunking all day, but I play simulation, real-life basketball, so that never happens. Play it the right way, not the arcade way.
Edit the sliders, change settings, etc.