Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

QBs
1. Joe Montana
2. Tom Brady
3. Peyton Manning
4. Steve Young
5. Brett Favre
6. Dan Marino

TBs
1. Jim Brown
2. Barry Sanders
3. Walter Payton
4. Gale Sayers
5. O.J. Simpson
6. Earl Campbell

WRs
1. Randy Moss
2. Larry Fitzgerald
3. Lynn Swann
4. Andre Johnson
5. Art Monk
6. Terrell Owens

TEs
1. Tony Gonzalez
2. Antonio Gates
3. Kellen Winslow
4. Ozzie Newsome
5. John Mackey
6. Ben Coates

OL
1. Anthony Munoz
2. John Hannah
3. Bruce Matthews
4. Jonathan Ogden
5. Jackie Slater
6. Orlando Pace

DEs
1. Reggie White
2. Bruce Smith
3. Deacon Jones
4. Michael Strahan
5. Doug Atkins
6. Gino Marchetti

DTs
1. Joe Greene
2. Alan Page
3. Cortez Kennedy
4. Warren Sapp
5. Dan Hampton
6. Russell Maryland

LBs
1. Lawrence Taylor
2. Jack Lambert
3. Ray Lewis
4. Derrick Thomas
5. Jack Ham
6. Junior Seau

DBs
1. Deion Sanders
2. Ronnie Lott
3. Dick Lane
4. Rod Woodson
5. Mel Blount
6. Darrell Green

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

That is a terrible WR list. Absolutely horrible. I'll let you figure out why.

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

+1
That may be the worst opinion ranking WRs ever.

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

Turrible list as expected. Nice, a guy who takes plays off is the top WR. If Moss had Rice's work ethic, then he probably would be at the top. Sanders at #2 is shit. How can Montana be #1 when he was surrounded by so much talent (using your argument)? There's so many things wrong, but I'll stop there.

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

dont feed the trolls

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

Emmit Smith is a top 5 RB. No doubt.

So is LT.

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

OP clearly created a new account simply to troll the NFL forum, don't even bother replying to his threads.

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

so is this just based on prime years and not an entire career's worth of play?

that is the only way some of this is justified...

how can Fitz's career be better than Rice's?


Swann at #3?

Gale, OJ, or Earl over Emmitt Smith?


and if you are just using prime years, then 2006 Tomlinson would be #1

this ranking system of your needs work

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

They banned you again, Prime?

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

no I retired the ~primetime~ account at 10,000 posts

I don't know why I did that, just felt like it for some reason

I just wanted to post with a new name...

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

Surely you could have done better than playmaker...should have gone with -NeonDeion-

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

I will retire this one at 10,000 if I am still around

and maybe then -neon- will hit the scene...


Michael "The Playmaker" Irvin was pimp as f*ck too though...he needs some respect...:)

edit: speaking of "The Playmaker"...he was better than a couple of the WRs on that list

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

a real WR list would go something like this:

-Rice
-Moss
-Owens
-Hutson


^^^ top tier

then there is a big mash of:

-Irvin
-Carter
-Brown
-Bruce
-Harrison
-Alworth
-Largent
-Holt

then there are the new guys that probably will make the list but it is too early now:

-Fitz
-Andre
-Calvin
-Ocho
-Smith
-Dez Bryant (:D )

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

I used to think David Boston would be an all-time great when I was younger. I was wrong.

Re: Ranking The All-Time NFLers
 

Rice is a near consensus top 5 all time NFL talent. For a guy who talks alot about the Cowboys O-Line, how can you have Montana at 1 without even ranking Rice? What about Hutson? Dude was Rice before Rice. You've got to be sh*tting with Fitz and Johnson there.

Your list of QBs totally disrespects some former greats
Unitas? Elway?

Sharpe deserves mention as a TE

RB is difficult to gauge, but I'd have to say Emmitt Smith, LT and Dickerson deserve to be on there, over Campbell for sure but debateable with Simpson and Sayers. But, this is largely my opinion