2004 NFL Draft QBs: What do you think about them now?

[leopoldstotch]

i think we have enough of a sample size to get a good feeling about their NFL careers.

Ben Roethlisberger
Eli Manning
Philip Rivers
Matt Schaub

where do you rank them? is this the best QB class of all time? how do they compare to the heralded 1983 class (Elway, Kelly, Marino, O'Brien)?

[scott0326]

Roethlisberger
Rivers


Manning
Schaub

[leopoldstotch]

i think people argue between rivers and manning. they both had similar careers, and eli has been significantly better his last 4 years compared to his first 3. sure the numbers show rivers is clearly better than eli, but i feel manning and rivers are closer than we think.

[GOBB]

Originally Posted by scott0326

Roethlisberger
Rivers


Manning
Schaub

This

[irondarts]

Ben Roethlisberger
Eli Manning
Philip Rivers
Matt Schaub

This order, Manning over Rivers only because he has a ring.

[knickballer]

Rivers
Eli
Big Ben
Schaub

[scott0326]

Originally Posted by knickballer

Rivers
Eli
Big Ben
Schaub

How the hell is Eli better then Roethlisberger?

[Sarcastic]

How about rank the receiving cores that each QB has had?

[ballinhun8]

Big Ben
Eli
Rivers

Schaub

[Skywalker]

Originally Posted by irondarts

Ben Roethlisberger
Eli Manning
Philip Rivers
Matt Schaub

This order, Manning over Rivers only because he has a ring.

lol Rivers is better than Manning ffs what are summaya SMOKING?

[franchise#3]

Joe Montana



Roethlisberger
Rivers


Schaub
Manning

[leopoldstotch]

the way manning has been playing this year, i won't be opposed to putting him 2nd.

[leopoldstotch]

after tonight, i definitely feel better placing rivers 3rd in the list.