for atl fans: trade proposal

[kurupt]

IM just wondering what charlie v is worth,

would you do a childress and zaza for charlie v and (araujo or bonner or pape )

or

charlie v plus the 1st plus mo pete plus araujo, for the 5th, smith, childress, and zaza

[JohnnySic]

I'm not a Hawks fan but I dont do that trade. Zaza by himself is better than what's coming back.

[JohnnySic]

Oh, wait, if the Hawks are getting the #1 pick, then I guess its worthwhile.

[craigthomasb]

the only trade id do is charlie for #5 staright up

raps then draft gay and marcus williams

williams
peterson
gay
bosh
pryzbila

laughing

[kumquat]

I think Charlie is worth more as a trading piece than a player for Toronto

[bonez26]

Charlie is a better player then Zaza and for that matter so is Mo pete.

[JohnnySic]

Zaza is a 7 footer who plays big, can board and defend the lane, and will improve going forward.

Charlie is a peaked tweener who's on his way to emulating Donyell Marshall.

[kurupt]

im pretty sure hawks would trade zaza for cv straight up,

[JohnnySic]

^Maybe the Hawks would do it but that doesn't mean its smart.

[JohnnySic]

Come to think of it, the Hawks already have 32,000 small forwards; why not add Charlie to the collection?

[Ricardo Tubbs]

Zaza by himself is better than what's coming back.

Zaza is a 7 footer who plays big, can board and defend the lane

Exactly when did Zaza Pachulia become Dwight Howard?

[bonez26]

Zaza Pachulia avg last year:

11.7 ppg, 7.9 rpg, 1.1 apg 1.14 spg & 0.5 bpg in 31.4 mpg

Charlie V had in hist rookie season:

13.0 ppg (and scored 48 once), 6.4 rpg, 1.1 apg 0.74 spg, 0.78bpg in 29.1mpg

So charlie is actually doing better in his first year in les time on the floor and has vast potential.

Zaza Pachulia is never gonna be the player Charlie is or is going to be.

[JohnnySic]

and has vast potential.

Just not seeing it. I think he's peaked. Think Shane Battier.

[bonez26]

If you watched him night in and night out you just see little flashes of things that he can do...just makes you think if he works on his skills he could become very good.

[DoubleTech]

no sense argueing with sic, he's the same guy who believes al jefferson is a future allstar, when everyone else knows he's as good as he's ever going to be.

charlie V has peaked? get outta here!
the guy is just STARTING to figure out what he can do with all that talent.

i'm waiting for sic's yearly prediction that the Celts will make the playoffs.