ISH All-time Top 25 Guards Project: #10 - John Stockton vs. Jason Kidd

[RRR3]

[Clippersfan86]

. I actually liked him. What most people wouldn't know was for about 6 seasons combined he averaged like 14 ppg. He was a very solid player. On the Cavs though... he averaged like 7 ppg.

[Droid101]

I think you fail to see the flaw in your reasoning. I don't think Nash would have sniffed an MVP back when Kidd was in contention. He also would not have been a top 5 player at any time either.

Kidd was second in MVP votes and couldn't even make the first team all nba.

It depends on if he dragged a 20-win team to a 60-win team with his addition being the only major change.

[G.O.A.T]

No more NASH talk in this thread....

STOCKTON vs. KIDD

[Clippersfan86]

No more NASH talk in this thread....

STOCKTON vs. KIDD

. Yes please! Let go of the Nash vs Kidd thing!

[EricForman]

i vote for Stockton.

[G.O.A.T]

i vote for Stockton.

Do you want to vote, or just chime in?

I added you as a contributor, but not a voter.

[KGMN]

I'll take John Stockton here.

[Clippersfan86]

Do you want to vote, or just chime in?

I added you as a contributor, but not a voter.

G.O.A.T did you add me as a voter?

[G.O.A.T]

G.O.A.T did you add me as a voter?

If no one objects, your vote will count starting in the next poll.

[IGOTGAME]

It depends on if he dragged a 20-win team to a 60-win team with his addition being the only major change.

im confused? are you saying Kidd isnt capable of doubling a team's win total? you are aware he has done it.

[Droid101]

im confused? are you saying Kidd isnt capable of doubling a team's win total? you are aware he has done it.

The year he was "almost" MVP?

Back on topic: Stockton is better than Kidd. Stockton's assist and steals records won't be touched, ever. He's just that good.

[Clippersfan86]

If no one objects, your vote will count starting in the next poll.

Okay. So Stockton vs Magic or w/e my vote counts. For now I'll contribute what I can.

[L.Kizzle]

Damn, I was gonna write something but it looks like it's a wrap.

[Miller for 3]

I haven't seen a good argument for Stockton yet, just "he has the assist record" type posts. Why wasn't Mark Jackson a part of this project then? He played forever and put up a ton of assists in a time when assists were given out more frequently as well.