ISH's #19 Player of Alltime

[bballnoob1192]

anyways im voting for elgin baylor

[RobertdeMeijer]

John Havlicek

[nayte]

I'm goin to go with Robinson too.Yeah he got schooled by Hakeem once(I think) but overall the dude had a farking awesome career.

[RRR3]

The admiral. Dirk Isn't better than him.

[raiderfan19]

The admiral. Dirk Isn't better than him.

Dirk is different than him. The more natural comparison is kg and drob is better than kg

[ClutchBucketz]

The Admiral

[Jan95]

David Robinson.

[miles berg]

Isiah Thomas, no doubt, one of the greats.

[SpecialQue]

Mikan.

[Charlie Sheen]

this list got dumped on when people put dirk this high up on the chart. im not even a dirk hater but this ranking for dirk is only because of how recent he won his championship. in about three years im pretty sure people wont have him in top 20. cuz he prolly wont win another title, and then he'll just be forgotten

back in 2008 buncha posters had pierce in the top 20... dirk is better than pierce but u get the point

[Charlie Sheen]

2x mvp. career averages 27/7/7. rank#19 should be taking enough of a hit for having half a career ahead of him and falling short of championship

lebron

[ShaqAttack3234]

2x mvp. career averages 27/7/7. rank#19 should be taking enough of a hit for having half a career ahead of him and falling short of championship

lebron

Agreed, not that it matters, but I vote for Lebron once again.

He's ending up below players who clearly weren't as good, several of which didn't have any more team success in their prime and now we'll see some players whose primes didn't even last more than a year or 2 longer and were worse playoff performers(Robinson) get ranked over him.

[pegasus]

Agreed, not that it matters, but I vote for Lebron once again.

He's ending up below players who clearly weren't as good, several of which didn't have any more team success in their prime and now we'll see some players whose primes didn't even last more than a year or 2 longer and were worse playoff performers(Robinson) get ranked over him.

He's got all the time in the world to move up the ladder. I think it is fair to keep him out of the top-20 for now.

[ShaqAttack3234]

He's got all the time in the world to move up the ladder. I think it is fair to keep him out of the top-20 for now.

Well, we've probably seen his peak(2009), and we've seen him as an elite player for 7 full seasons('05-'11). David Robinson only had 7 seasons before his injury in '96-'97. So if longevity is the issue then I don't understand why Robinson is probably going to be voted ahead of him.

I can understand Malone based on his freakish longevity, though personally I don't agree with ranking a guy ahead when his longevity didn't help him accomplish anymore and his peak was clearly inferior.

[Fatal9]

LeBron