'Superbad' or 'American Pie' (VOTE)

[Im Still Ballin]

Superbad's commentary is a must-watch. My favorite DVD commentary ever.

Judd Apatow brings his 9 year old daughter and Jonah won't stop swearing so he gets pissed off and leaves. The commentary is an absolute riot, highly recommended.

[imdaman99]

I liked Superbad a lot but I grew up with me and my buddies watching American Pie. I know the rest of them weren't that good but the 1st was def part of an era.

[SouBeachTalents]

I liked Superbad a lot but I grew up with me and my buddies watching American Pie. I know the rest of them weren't that good but the 1st was def part of an era.

I disagree bro. I actually thought the sequel was good. Not as good as the original obv, but a really solid follow up. The vast majority of sequels, specifically comedy ones suck so that's a rarity. And I liked Reunion too, far from a masterpiece but I thought it was solid. Wedding however was definitely a misfire, it's by far the weakest one and it's legitimately just Stifler acting like a retard the entire time

[TheCorporation]

Superbad 100%

I'm embarassed of our forum to see it so close.

[97 bulls]

American Pie. How can we forget about that scence where the girl comes over for a study date.

[vetlantram]

American Pie

[fsvr54]

American Pie. That's what my generation grew up on

[Im Still Ballin]

I voted American Pie to make it closer.

Superbad wins 11-8.

57.89% to 42.11%

[Street Hunger]

I have trouble comparing these movies because American Pie feels like a cultural institution, thanks to all the sequels.