Melo or Pierce

[Akrazotile]

Are you going to give your opinion on this matter or are you fine on that high horse?

Comparable talent, both get too carried away with hero ball at times but Pierce does it less and is easily the smarter player and more consistent defender, he's my choice.

[IncarceratedBob]

Pierce played better D but I still prefer Melo

[tontoz]

Only clutch when he had Ray Allen/Rondo/KG to help out. When did Melo have that kind of support? Thats alright take your time, I'll wait

Spoken like a true kid. Pierce had a clutch reputation going back to the days when Antoine Walker was on the team.

I am taking Pierce. More efficient scorer, better passer and not as much of a ball stopper as Melo. Melo's career best TS of 56.8% is Pierce's career average. Rebounding is basically even. PP's rebounding has tapered off late in his career and he is till only .6 rpg behind Melo.

[zoom17]

Paul pierce

[Y2Gezee]

Better player Melo. Better career...Pierce. At the age of 30 Melo has accomplished more.

[JohnFreeman]

Prime Pierce could beat Prime Kobe in 1 on 1

[AintNoSunshine]

Don't anybody bring up anything about winning, Pierce had been a career loser until he got Kevin freakin Garnett and Ray Allen by his side.

[Inferno]

Gimme Melo

[Y2Gezee]

Prime Pierce could beat Prime Kobe in 1 on 1

So could Prime Melo