*****All-Time NBA Players Peak Draft*****

[1987_Lakers]

Top 3 Teams
Team 1
Team 3
Team 6

Middle
Team 8
Team 9
Team 4

Bottom 3
Team 5
Team 7
Team 2

Placed in brackets head to head, would be a better way to decide IMO.

Thanks for your input, why do you have team 5 so low? Realgm currenty has them #2. Team 1 IMO could really use some more shooting, but they are somewhat underrated. I probably have them somewhere between top 4-5.

Realgm votes
1 - 1987_Lakers - 11 votes
2 - SouBeachTalents - 4 votes
3 - Johnny & Im Still Ballin - 3 votes

I agree with you having Team 6 (AlternativeAcc) in the top 3.

Team 2 to me is by far the worst.

[post]

she is so intimidating she couldn't get her name capitalized here or even mentioned on the other site

also incorrect assumptions about lineups which is another sign of fear

[L.Kizzle]

Thanks for your input, why do you have team 5 so low? Realgm currenty has them #2. Team 1 IMO could really use some more shooting, but they are somewhat underrated. I probably have them somewhere between top 4-5.

Realgm votes
1 - 1987_Lakers - 11 votes
2 - SouBeachTalents - 4 votes
3 - Johnny & Im Still Ballin - 3 votes

I agree with you having Team 6 (AlternativeAcc) in the top 3.

Team 2 to me is by far the worst.

Man, I don't care where real gm have em at lol.
I did this as I was goin to bed, and team 5 kept falling for some reason. But I was sleepy so that may have something to do with it.
I will probably go in depth on each team later today.

[warriorfan]

Why are you voting at real GM? That place is low iq.

[1987_Lakers]

Why are you voting at real GM? That place is low iq.

Wasn't my original idea. AlternativeAcc. was the first to suggest it and I thought it would be better to make a poll there compared to ISH with all these trolls running around.

[AlternativeAcc.]

If it helps you feel better I thought you had a top 3 team in this draft behind my team and SouBeachTealents. That realgm poster might be right in saying your team is getting underrated because Walton & T-Mac's peaks were so short.

SouBeachTalents team is absolutely stacked in top heavy talent, just think my team fits a bit better.

I agree those are the top 3 teams

I also think my team beats yours head to head...


I think my team spaces the floor better AND passes much better while having two elite rim protectors. Stockton is a good 3 point shooter but on very low volume. We know Duncan can guard Wallace effectively while being a much more dominant offensive player... Jordan is the best scorer on both teams but I have Payton and Dumars off the bench too while having 3 elite rim protectors. So my team would probably nullify him the best.

Bench wise you have two great shooters in Allen and pierce but they're not great defensively, especially Allen. I have Mullins whose a great shooter and overall scorer too. I think my bench is better too if we just compared them 5v5

[AlternativeAcc.]

Why are you voting at real GM? That place is low iq.

Damn, didn't know that

[1987_Lakers]

I agree those are the top 3 teams

I also think my team beats yours head to head...


I think my team spaces the floor better AND passes much better while having two elite rim protectors. Stockton is a good 3 point shooter but on very low volume. We know Duncan can guard Wallace effectively while being a much more dominant offensive player... Jordan is the best scorer on both teams but I have Payton and Dumars off the bench too while having 3 elite rim protectors. So my team would probably nullify him the best.

Bench wise you have two great shooters in Allen and pierce but they're not great defensively, especially Allen. I have Mullins whose a great shooter and overall scorer too. I think my bench is better too if we just compared them 5v5

Sorry bro, even the poster who picked your team in the realgm thread admitted he was biased and was secretly drooling over my team.

[L.Kizzle]

Sorry bro, even the poster who picked your team in the realgm thread admitted he was biased and was secretly drooling over my team.

Which team is yours?

[AlternativeAcc.]

Sorry bro, even the poster who picked your team in the realgm thread admitted he was biased and was secretly drooling over my team.

My team objectively spaces the floor better, passes much better at almost every position including the bench, and defends the paint better, while having more versatility with AK47 off the bench who could easily guard Wallace or bosh while having much more offensive impact than both. I could rotate AK47 with either walton or Duncan if needed, and he gives me elite offensive impact still with great off ball play and passing.

They voted for your team off name value and assumptions, but when you analyze our teams head to head my team is better and has all the pieces to nullify your biggest strengths.

[1987_Lakers]

Which team is yours?

Team 3

[1987_Lakers]

Iamgine crying because his rotations were messed up, I fixed his rotations to look more respectful more than 12 hours ago and he still hasn't received a vote while I have received like 4 more votes.

The reason why I listed the teams like that and not just a list is because it gives posters a better sense if they fit or not.

[AlternativeAcc.]

Match up style while providing 2 year peak stats and a general strategy for each team would be far more accurate.

Listing both of our teams head to head with stats and strategy provided would yield a much closer result than what the poll suggests. I think your team pops the most because they see Jordan as GOAT, Stockton as best passer, Robinson as most athletic center, Allen as best 3 point shooter, Wallace as a stretch 4, and kawhi as a two player and recency bias.


But it's far more nuanced than that.

[1987_Lakers]

Lol. A realgm mod just threatened to lock my thread because I keep bumping it. Damn those people are uptight.

[SouBeachTalents]

Lol. A realgm mod just threatened to lock my thread because I keep bumping it. Damn those people are uptight.

Yeah, for all the shit mods let posters get away with here, they seem WAY too uptight about shit over there. So while they for sure have better, more nuanced discussions there, the rigidness makes it almost a joyless place to post

The perfect forum would find a happy medium between this place and that one.