-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by tpols
Dude 2004 Kevin Garnett was probably the most versatile player of all time. You guys are straight up clowning. 
Draymond is the overall better ball handler, playmaker, and already has an established 2 man game with Curry. Obviously KG is better, but don’t really need the other things he provides.
Overall a defensive frontline of Walton/Draymond is more versatile . Dray could guard 1-5 more effectively than KG.
Last edited by 1987_Lakers; 06-03-2025 at 03:34 PM.
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by 3ba11
Agreed.
Curry
MJ
Bird
KG
Robinson
^^^ No plodding big to hamper offensive movement, thus maximizing the capacity for dynasty ball movement.
Prime Wilt in Robinson or KG's place might work better but I like the jumpshooting ability of Robinson & KG... 5 jumpshoters out there but also great/goat post play from 4 of the 5 guys
Bird at the 3 in today’s game would be exposed on defense. He is your classic 4 in today’s league.
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by 1987_Lakers
Draymond is the overall better ball handler, playmaker, and already has an established 2 man game with Curry. Obviously KG is better, but don’t really need the other things he provides.
Overall a defensive frontline of Walton/Draymond works better.
Absolutely absurd take.
2004 TWolves Kevin Garnett had great big man handles and playmaking / passing ability. He was arguably better at that than he was at scoring. And was an even better defender and rebounder than Dray.
I'm going to hold this opinion against you forever. 
But Klay over MJ might take the cake.
-
Re: all time starting 5

 Originally Posted by 1987_Lakers
Bird at the 3 in today’s game would be exposed on defense. He is your classic 4 in today’s league.
Luka works at the 1, so Bird would work anywhere he wants.
Dominique, Dr. J, Bernard King, or even Shawn Kemp has famous stories of being dominated by Bird...
Athletic guys like Walter Davis or Gervin - destroyed by Bird... So no... Bird would be fine
and he could play the 4.. He would also be carrying the ball a lot in today's game (above), which would allow him to play guard.
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by tpols
Absolutely absurd take.
2004 TWolves Kevin Garnett had great big man handles and playmaking / passing ability. He was arguably better at that than he was at scoring. And was an even better defender and rebounder than Dray.
I'm going to hold this opinion against you forever.
But Klay over MJ might take the cake.
Stop. KG was a great playmaker, but he never ran an offense the way Draymond did. For the Wolves, Cassell was the one doing most of the playmaking, for the Warriors it was always Draymond year in and year out.
Plus we don’t want fake tough guys on our team. 
Dude got punched by Anthony Peeler and did nothing.
Last edited by 1987_Lakers; 06-03-2025 at 06:30 PM.
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by 3ba11
Luka works at the 1, so Bird would work anywhere he wants.
Dominique, Dr. J, Bernard King, or even Shawn Kemp has famous stories of being dominated by Bird...
Athletic guys like Walter Davis or Gervin - destroyed by Bird... So no... Bird would be fine
and he could play the 4.. He would also be carrying the ball a lot in today's game (above), which would allow him to play guard.
There is a reason why McHale was always guarding guys like Dominique and not Bird. Bird would get cooked guarding 3s of today.
-
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by 1987_Lakers
There is a reason why McHale was always guarding guys like Dominique and not Bird. Bird would get cooked guarding 3s of today.
^^^ Pure fabricated bs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6QAX7sbVa8
-
Trumptard triggerer
Re: all time starting 5
-
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by RRR3
So your counter is a video of Dominique abusing Bird?
STUPIDBALL 
No, but a younger Bird guarded Dominique, Dr. J, and all the quick perimeter players.
-
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by 1987_Lakers
There is a reason why McHale was always guarding guys like Dominique and not Bird. Bird would get cooked guarding 3s of today.
Another thing - in addition to the younger bird guarding Dominique, Dr J and all.the SF's, I want 2 hybrids at the forward spots that can play SF and PF, so that's why Bird/KG are perfect..
Robinson can also play the 3-5 spots.. Again, a lineup of MJ, Curry, Bird, KG and Robinson entails 5 jumpshoters and 4 great post players, so that's great versatility, plus several "Pippens" for MJ to light that fire under (KG, Robinson)
-
Trumptard triggerer
Re: all time starting 5
Some of your guys lineups would get obliterated by the current Pacers lol, let alone OKC. If you're still ignoring spacing when building all time teams in 2025, well you haven't learned much as the game has become less primitive.
-
The Wizard
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by SouBeachTalents
I'm honestly surprised at all the Kobe mentions, I don't think he'd be a good fit in an all-time lineup at all. I also don't understand why anyone would choose him over Jordan when he's essentially just a worse version of him.
Did you watch the Redeem Team documentary?
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by ralph_i_el
Did you watch the Redeem Team documentary?
I watched the games during those Olympics. He actually wasn't that great of a fit, took the most shots on the team, but was still outscored by LeBron & Wade.
The funny thing is, I vividly remember Kobe telling the media that he was mostly going to focus on defense during those Olympics, but he couldn't help himself.
-
NBA Legend and Hall of Famer
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by ralph_i_el
Did you watch the Redeem Team documentary?
Got em.
Kobe was the bonafide leader on that team behind the scenes and on the court. Took all the toughest covers and then closed out the Gold Medal game in late 4th quarter.
-
Re: all time starting 5
 Originally Posted by tpols
Dude 2004 Kevin Garnett was probably the most versatile player of all time. You guys are straight up clowning. 
This is true, but I don't recall seeing KG doing much of that from the perimeter the way that Draymond did during his peak. KG was a good playmaker but probably a better passer. I think the example of using Draymond works. Maybe if KG was from this era, then things would have been different.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|